1.png

“I received toning treatment, but the darker spots are still there.”

“I had several sessions, but my skin does not feel as clear as I expected.”

“I think I have melasma, dark spots, and an uneven overall skin tone.”

 

In reality, facial pigmentation is much more often caused by a mixture of different factors rather than a single problem.

 

On the surface, they may all look like similar brown patches, but inside the skin, melasma, solar lentigines, freckles, post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation, and vascular reactions may coexist.

 

That is why it is important to first distinguish which pigment exists at which depth and for what reason, rather than simply saying, “You need a certain number of toning sessions.”

 

There are many laser devices and treatment methods, and many people have heard of dual toning.

 

Dual toning is a concept that combines two treatment directions to refine the overall skin tone.

 

The exact composition may differ from clinic to clinic.

 

Some approaches combine IPL with low-fluence 1064 nm Q-switched Nd laser, while others explain it as a method that separately targets epidermal pigmentation and background pigmentation.

 

The key point is that broadly spread melasma-like background pigmentation, prominent dark spots, and uneven overall tone should not be treated as one single problem.

 

They need to be assessed and designed separately.

 

Dual toning is not “a stronger laser treatment done twice.”

 

It is better understood as a treatment that adjusts different targets in different ways, within the range that the skin can tolerate.

 

Why is dual toning needed?

2.png

Melasma often appears as a broad and hazy pigmentation pattern over the cheekbones and cheeks.

 

In these cases, it may be more appropriate to gently regulate the melanin response with low energy, rather than repeatedly using strong spot treatment.

 

On the other hand, lesions with relatively clear borders, such as solar lentigines or freckles, may remain as dot-like spots even after repeated toning sessions.

 

In some cases, separate spot treatment may be needed.

 

The problem is that these two patterns often coexist on the same face.

 

Background pigmentation needs to be reduced carefully, while prominent spots in certain areas may need to be treated separately.

 

If only one method is repeated in this situation, satisfaction may be lower.

 

If toning alone is continued for a long time, the overall background may become slightly brighter, but darker spots can still remain.

 

On the other hand, if only strong spot treatment is repeatedly performed, PIH can occur in skin that also has melasma.

 

That is why dual toning is not about “stronger treatment.”

 

It is closer to an approach that separates broad pigmentation from prominent pigmentation and treats them accordingly.

 

Why dark spots may remain even after long-term toning

3.png

Toning can help gently adjust broadly spread background pigmentation.

 

However, not all brown spots improve well with toning alone.

 

Especially older dark spots or well-defined lesions may remain as visible spots even when the overall skin tone becomes slightly brighter.

 

This can make patients feel, “My skin looks a little clearer, but the spots I care about are still there.”

 

On the other hand, if strong spot treatment is repeatedly performed on skin with mixed melasma, post-inflammatory hyperpigmentation may occur, or melasma may become more noticeable.

 

Ultimately, the important point is not receiving as many laser sessions as possible.

 

The key is to gently adjust broad background pigmentation, selectively reduce prominent lesions where needed, and prioritize recovery if the skin is in a sensitive state.

 

What does the study say?

4.png

The study referenced here was published by Na and colleagues in Annals of Dermatology in 2012.

 

It included 20 patients with mixed-type melasma, meaning melasma with both epidermal and dermal components.

The treatment combined one session of IPL and four sessions of low-fluence Q-switched Nd laser.

 

The study evaluated the melanin index, erythema index, and modified MASI score before and after treatment.

 

Both indices significantly decreased after treatment, and the modified MASI score decreased by an average of 59.35%.

 

During an average follow-up period of 5.9 months, no clinical worsening was observed, and 60% of the patients did not want additional treatment.

 

This study shows that melasma treatment is not only about repeating one wavelength for a long time.

 

It also shows that different types of energy can be combined depending on the skin condition.

 

When can dual toning be considered?

5.png

※ This photo was taken of the same person under identical conditions. Results and recovery may vary by individual.

Dual toning may be considered when the overall face looks dull and there are also scattered dark spots.

 

It may also be considered when broad melasma is present over the cheekbones and cheeks, with dot-like pigmentation such as solar lentigines layered on top.

 

If the skin tone still looks uneven after long-term toning, it may not simply mean that the number of sessions was insufficient.

 

It may be necessary to first check whether different types of pigmentation are mixed.

 

In this situation, it is helpful to assess diagnostic images such as MarkVu together with visual examination, and to distinguish whether the issue is background pigmentation, prominent lesions, or redness.

 

However, dual toning is not necessary for everyone.

 

If the pigmentation is very superficial and simple, spot-focused treatment may be more efficient.

 

If the skin is highly sensitive or inflammation keeps recurring, restoring the skin barrier may need to come before laser treatment.

 

If there has been recent tanning or active acne inflammation, aggressive treatment can become an additional source of irritation.

 

Rather than thinking of dual toning as a “package that is good for everyone,” it is more accurate to understand it as a combination treatment selected after separating and assessing the skin condition.

 

Precautions before and after treatment

7.png

After treatment, temporary erythema, heat sensation, dryness, and stinging may occur.

 

If spot treatment or IPL is included, the treated areas may temporarily look darker or develop thin crusts.

 

Please avoid forcibly removing crusts or using scrubs.

 

Irritating the skin before it has recovered can make PIH last longer.

Sun protection is essential.

 

Melasma and dark spots are strongly affected by UV exposure, so even after proper treatment, repeated sun exposure can make them darker again.

 

It is also better to temporarily control activities that increase heat sensation, such as sauna, alcohol, and excessive exercise.

Skin with melasma can react sensitively to heat, friction, and inflammation, so lifestyle management should be considered together with treatment.

 

To summarize, dual toning is not simply a treatment where the laser is performed twice.

 

It is closer to a treatment that separates broad background pigmentation, prominent dark spots, and skin sensitivity, then adjusts each factor with an appropriate method.

 

If darker spots remain after long-term toning, it may not mean that toning was insufficient.

 

The lesion may have been a different target from the beginning.

 

On the other hand, if the skin became sensitive after treating only the spots aggressively, melasma or skin barrier problems may have been present together.

 

Is the dullness on your face caused by melasma?

 

Is it caused by dark spots?

 

Is it caused by redness?

 

Or are several problems mixed together?

 

It is better to first identify these factors before deciding on the treatment direction :)

 

This was Director Won Dae-han.

 

Thank you for reading.

 

Source:
Na SY, Cho S, Lee JH.
Intense Pulsed Light and Low-Fluence Q-Switched Nd Laser Treatment in Melasma Patients.
Annals of Dermatology. 2012;24(3):267-273.

This article is intended to provide general medical information.


Actual suitability for treatment, laser type, energy, number of sessions, and treatment intervals may vary depending on each individual’s skin tone, type of pigmentation, presence of redness, skin sensitivity, and previous treatment history.


After treatment, erythema, stinging, dryness, pigmentation, and other reactions may occur, so an accurate diagnosis and treatment plan should be determined through consultation.

TOP

Journey of Beauty
PRIMI CLINIC

image
promo
  • KakaoTalk
  • Whatsapp
  • Blog Blog Blog
  • Phone
  • KakaoTalk
  • Whatsapp
  • Phone